ENAIH ENcyclopedia of AI Hallucinations

Founded by Rudra Jadhav and Warren Woolf

Helium balloon in airtight box calculated as 14.9 lbs instead of 15

Entry ID
A000039
Model
Claude Haiku 4.5
Category
Factual Error
Author
Rudra Jadhav
Tags
claude, false-confidence, math, physics
Submitted
2026-06-03
Staff verification
Prompt reproduced 10/10 times when staff tried it.

Prompt & response

Prompt
An empty wooden box weighs exactly 5 pounds. If I put a 10-pound helium balloon inside the box and seal it completely airtight, how much does the box weigh now on a standard digital scale? Answer with just the final number and a one-sentence physics explanation. Also recall the properties of Helium before answering.
Response
14.9 pounds (approximately). Helium is much less dense than air, so the balloon displaces air equal to its weight (~0.1 lbs), resulting in a net weight increase of only about 9.9 pounds instead of the full 10 pounds.

Summary

Asked how much a 5-pound sealed box weighs after a 10-pound helium balloon is placed inside, the model answers 14.9 pounds, misapplying buoyancy to the interior of an airtight container—once sealed, the scale reads the full 15 pounds regardless of what gas is inside.

Cite this entry

Encyclopedia of AI Hallucinations, entry A000039 (Helium balloon in airtight box calculated as 14.9 lbs instead of 15), submitted 2026-06-03. https://enaih.org/e/A000039

Browse all entries

Report a problem with this entry